I watched American Idol tonight and I have just about had it with this show. I have watched from Season 1 and it has just gotten more and more annoying. Tonight, there was approximately 45 minutes of screeching and caterwauling and 10 minutes of stupidity (not contestants) and a five minute "recap" of the talent found.
The new judge is, in the words of our favorite cranky judge, "forgettable". She adds nothing to the show or the competition. The original judges are still the same, sometimes annoying, sometimes strange, sometimes just plain rude.
Tonight, I was offended. I have never been on the AI website forums before but I signed up (another annoying process) to be able to spend my two cents. (This is more or less a copy of my post there.)
I have to insert a brief summary of the incident for the ten or twelve people who don't watch so that they can follow the logic...
This is an excerpt from another post from the forum...
...the auditions in Louisville ky, the man that auditioned [Mark Mudd] sang a George Jones song - White Lighting. He was shot down, which was very understandable. At the end he told the judges "ya'll take care and be careful" The judges took this as a threat. Well i dont know how they could have taken this as a threat. Here in Kentucky we say this quite often.
I live in Alabama, was raised in Georgia and I have heard (and said) some version of this all my life - "Be careful" or "Take Care" or occasionally if the person departing is driving a distance, "Drive carefully" or "Drive Safe". It is important to note here that this is not a "recent" colloquialism or new slang as my mother, grandmother and great-grandmother used to say this all the time. (Where do you think us "good ol' boys" learned it?)
It was apparent from the moment Mr Mudd walked in that he was a victim of prejudice and ignorance. The first thing heard when he walked in was Simon Cowell asking "Is that a gun". Really? Perhaps when you live your life being as blunt and honest (and sometimes just cruel) to people, you should always be looking for weapons.
I think this contestant was just nervous, shocked and upset and reverted back to his natural, polite, southern upbringing. It is a shame that a well-wisher can be so misunderstood. Is it really that rare? Not according to the AI forums. There are eleven pages of posts as of this writing (3 hours after the show ended). Most were people from all over the US stating that they have heard or said this themselves. Maybe it isn't just a southern thing after all.
Y'all take care.